• About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms
  • Contact
Friday, January 27, 2023
Financial Eye News
  • Home
  • Markets
    • Stock Market News
    • Commodities
    • Forex
    • Renewables
  • Cryptocurrency
    • Ultimate Guide to Crypto
  • Business
    • News
    • Companies
    • Technology
    • Climate
    • Politics
  • Reports
    • Ultimate Guide to Crypto
  • VideosNew
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Markets
    • Stock Market News
    • Commodities
    • Forex
    • Renewables
  • Cryptocurrency
    • Ultimate Guide to Crypto
  • Business
    • News
    • Companies
    • Technology
    • Climate
    • Politics
  • Reports
    • Ultimate Guide to Crypto
  • VideosNew
No Result
View All Result
Financial Eye News
No Result
View All Result

The truth about war is messy — just read Wikipedia

March 19, 2022
in Technology
Reading Time: 3 mins read
51 0
ADVERTISEMENT

The writer is a former FT Moscow bureau chief

Rarely, if ever, in the history of human conflict have contributors to encyclopedias been counted as combatants. But in the information war that is raging between Russia and Ukraine, the frontline is nowhere and everywhere — as one of Wikipedia’s editors has found to his cost.

According to local media reports, he was seized by the Belarusian security police in Minsk, charged with publishing “anti-Russian” information and detained. An active contributor to Russian language Wikipedia, he has contributed more than 200,000 edits. When some other members of Wikipedia’s small army of unpaid editors complained that the page entitled “Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine (2022)” violated Wikipedia’s neutral point of view, he responded: “Russian troops invaded the territory of Ukraine. It’s just a fact, not a point of view.”

The Kremlin has previously complained about Wikipedia, warning it might throttle the site in Russia. It has already passed a fake news law threatening to jail those who report disinformation for up to 15 years and has blocked most foreign media. It has disabled US social media sites, including Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. According to a report from the internet research site Tracking Exposed, it also appears to have persuaded TikTok, owned by China’s ByteDance, to filter out all non-Russian content from its video service in Russia, too.

Wikipedia is blocked in some countries, such as China and Myanmar, and is periodically censored elsewhere. For the moment, it remains accessible in Russia. But the site has long been a battleground between Russian and Ukrainian editors, resulting in parallel interpretations of the same events in different language editions. There was a particularly fierce online skirmish over the Maidan Revolution of 2014 and subsequent annexation of Crimea. “There is no policy on Wikipedia that prevents articles from differing across languages,” says Vidhu Goyal, lead communications specialist at the Wikimedia Foundation, the non-profit organisation that runs Wikipedia.

Yet in spite of Russia’s media crackdown and the passions inflamed by war, the Russian language page on the current invasion remains fact-filled and comprehensive. In places it diverges markedly from the Kremlin’s account. Wikipedia, designed to be a collective record of human knowledge, is not a rolling news service. But this page has been frequently updated and carries striking photographs and maps. It lists 563 sources, including RIA Novosti, the Washington Post and Meduza, although some links will no longer work in Russia without access to a virtual private network.

By any measure, Wikipedia is an extraordinary phenomenon. Launched in 2001, the online encyclopedia now contains more than 58m articles in 325 different languages. English language Wikipedia accounts for 11 per cent of these articles. About 3 per cent are in Russian and 2 per cent in Ukrainian.

Crowdsourcing truth does not sound like the best idea in partisan times. But although Wikipedia should not work in theory, it mostly does in practice. Content is produced by more than 280,000 unpaid contributors per month. In principle, anyone with an internet connection can edit an entry if they abide by guidelines. But a few contested pages, such as those on wars or political leaders, are protected and can only be modified by experienced editors.

Wikipedia certainly has its flaws, biases and blind spots. It has been gamed by trolls, corporate lobbyists and propagandists. It can be extremely difficult to remove errors in reports from reliable sources. What counts as a credible source can be hotly disputed. Wikipedia does not accept Russia’s RT or Sputnik news services, considering them outlets of state propaganda. But editors have also barred some well-known western media, including the Daily Mail, which they consider to be “generally unreliable”. 

For all its imperfections, Wikipedia remains one of the “last best places” on the internet, says Taha Yasseri, associate professor at University College Dublin. But we should not expect it to be the final arbiter of truth, he adds: “It is a very good place to start your research but a terrible place to end your research.”

It may be far from ideal that an online encyclopedia carries ever-changing, contested and kaleidoscopic versions of reality in different language editions. But, as we are seeing now, the disputes may just reflect reality. On some subjects, at least, truth is messy.

Source: Financial Times

ADVERTISEMENT
Share6Tweet4Share1SendShareSend

Related Posts

Technology

French Pornhub case shows how hard it is to regulate the internet

December 5, 2022
Technology

Covid chaos at Foxconn iPhone plant causes 29% revenue fall

December 5, 2022
Technology

Spiracle is turning niche literary fiction into audiobooks

December 5, 2022
Technology

Elon Musk, Matt Taibbi, and a Very Modern Media Maelstrom

December 5, 2022
Technology

The apps making business more social

December 4, 2022
Technology

Meloni pushes back on Italy’s shift into digital payments age

December 4, 2022

Popular Stories

  • AIG to launch cut-price IPO of life and asset management unit

    48 shares
    Share 19 Tweet 12
  • EY boss targets $10bn boost from Silicon Valley tie-ups after break-up

    32 shares
    Share 13 Tweet 8
  • Tesla delays plan to restore Shanghai output to pre-lockdown levels -memo

    32 shares
    Share 13 Tweet 8
  • TV production giant Banijay to go public via Arnault-backed Spac

    31 shares
    Share 12 Tweet 8
  • Nio to Invest $32.8M Building R&D Labs in Shanghai By Financial Eye

    30 shares
    Share 12 Tweet 8
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest News

Taylor Swift Fans Sue Ticketmaster’s Parent Company

December 5, 2022

Fisker trades down following price cut at Citi By Financial Eye

December 5, 2022

UAW president faces run-off election as reformers make gains

December 5, 2022

Felipe Valls, 89, Whose Cuban Restaurant Became a Political Hub, Dies

December 5, 2022

Longroad buys 98-MW solar farm in California

December 5, 2022
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

Financial Eye is one of the most trusted news sources for Financial News, global news and local USA news, we provide the news from the most trusted sources.

LEARN MORE »

Recent News

  • Taylor Swift Fans Sue Ticketmaster’s Parent Company
  • Fisker trades down following price cut at Citi By Financial Eye
  • UAW president faces run-off election as reformers make gains

Sections

  • Business
  • Climate
  • Commodities
  • Companies
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Forex
  • Green Energy
  • Latest Financial News
  • News
  • Politics
  • Stock Market News
  • Technology
  • Videos

© 2022 Financial Eye News Media

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Markets
    • Stock Market News
    • Commodities
    • Forex
    • Renewables
  • Cryptocurrency
    • Ultimate Guide to Crypto
  • Business
    • News
    • Companies
    • Technology
    • Climate
    • Politics
  • Reports
    • Ultimate Guide to Crypto
  • Videos

© 2022 Financial Eye News Media

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Subscribe To Our Daily News Round-Up.

The top ten most-read stories direct to your inbox

You have Successfully Subscribed!

You have Successfully Subscribed!

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.